2010MNRAS.406.1238E


Query : 2010MNRAS.406.1238E

2010MNRAS.406.1238E - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 406, 1238-1247 (2010/August-1)

When are extremely metal-deficient galaxies extremely metal deficient ?

EKTA B. and CHENGALUR J.N.

Abstract (from CDS):

Extremely metal-deficient (XMD) galaxies, by definition, have oxygen abundances ≤1/10 solar, and form a very small fraction of the local gas-rich, star-forming dwarf galaxy population. We examine their positions in the luminosity-metallicity (L-Z) and mass-metallicity (M-Z) planes, with respect to the L-Z and M-Z relations of other gas-rich, star-forming dwarf galaxies, viz., blue compact galaxies (BCGs) and dwarf irregular (dI) galaxies. We find that while the metallicities of some low-luminosity XMD galaxies are consistent with those expected from the L-Z relation, other XMD galaxies are deviant, and more so as the luminosity and/or metal-deficiency increases. We determine the 95 per cent confidence interval around the L-Z relation for BCGs, and find that its lower boundary is given by 12 + log (O/H) = - 0.177 MB + 4.87. We suggest that a galaxy should be regarded as XMD, in a statistically significant manner, only if it lies below this boundary in the L-Z plane. Of our sample of XMD galaxies, we find that more than half are XMD by this criterion, and in fact, nine of the galaxies lie below the 99.5 per cent confidence interval about the L-Z relation.

We also determine the gas mass fractions and chemical yields of galaxies in all three samples. We find that the effective chemical yield increases with increasing baryonic mass, consistent with what is expected if outflows of metal-enriched gas are important in determining the effective yield. XMD galaxies have lower effective yield than BCG/dI galaxies of similar baryonic mass. This suggests that some process, peculiar to XMD galaxies, has resulted in their low measured metallicities. Motivated by the fact that interactions are common in XMD galaxies, we suggest that improved (tidally driven) mixing of the interstellar media (ISM) in XMD galaxies leads to a lowering of both, the measured metallicity and the calculated effective yield. In isolated dwarf galaxies, the outer parts of the stellar envelope probably do not participate in the star formation, but are still generally included in the calculation of effective yield. This results in an overestimate of the effective yield. We suggest that XMD galaxies are deviant from the L-Z relation because of a combination of being gas rich (i.e. having processed less gas into stars) and having more uniform mixing of metals in their ISM.


Abstract Copyright: © 2010 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2010 RAS

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: abundances - galaxies: dwarf - galaxies: evolution

Simbad objects: 122

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 122
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 UGC 12894 G 00 00 22.55 +39 29 43.5   17       ~ 36 0
2 NAME Wolf-Lundmark-Melotte G 00 01 57.9 -15 27 50   11.50 11.10 10.93   ~ 690 2
3 LEDA 101427 H2G 00 24 25.9458009336 +14 04 10.732070028           ~ 20 0
4 UGC 300 AG? 00 30 04.10 +03 30 47.0   18       ~ 35 0
5 ESO 473-24 AG? 00 31 22.51 -22 45 57.5   16.11   15.87 17.7 ~ 58 1
6 2MASX J00531961-1024115 Sy1 00 53 19.6305260904 -10 24 11.957550084     17.14     ~ 11 0
7 IC 1613 GiC 01 04 48.4071 +02 07 10.185   10.42 10.01 9.77   ~ 1235 2
8 UGC 685 AG? 01 07 23.0321 +16 41 00.988 15.01 14.55 14.07     ~ 137 0
9 UGC 772 LSB 01 13 40.450 +00 52 39.16   17       ~ 63 0
10 SDSS J011914.28-093546.4 EmG 01 19 14.283 -09 35 46.23           ~ 18 0
11 UGC 993 H2G 01 25 34.1903008704 +07 59 24.703412028   15.6       ~ 44 0
12 6dFGS gJ012646.5-003845 H2G 01 26 46.6028219232 -00 38 46.165233696   17   15.46   ~ 56 0
13 UGC 1104 AG? 01 32 42.5190557016 +18 19 01.514434548 15.03 14.56 14.13 13.89   ~ 95 0
14 SDSS J013352.55+134209.5 EmG 01 33 52.555 +13 42 09.53           ~ 20 0
15 UGCA 20 bCG 01 43 14.6 +19 58 51   16       ~ 55 0
16 Z 412-24 H2G 01 44 41.3 +04 53 26 15.07 15.50 15.16 14.86 14.58 ~ 99 0
17 ESO 245-5 AG? 01 45 03.74 -43 35 52.9 13.45 12.92 12.63 12.51 12.8 ~ 140 1
18 LEDA 7896 AG? 02 04 25.598 -10 09 35.01   17       ~ 18 0
19 MCG-02-06-026 AG? 02 05 49.081 -09 49 17.62   15.14   16.77 15.2 ~ 35 0
20 SHOC 113 EmG 02 18 52.9115851920 -09 12 18.816216012           ~ 10 0
21 LEDA 994632 AG? 02 31 45.9791358288 -09 08 47.712166440           ~ 10 0
22 UGC 2023 GiG 02 33 18.20 +33 29 28.0   14.9   13.59   ~ 89 0
23 SHOC 137 H2G 02 48 15.9460059552 -08 17 16.258401096           ~ 14 0
24 SDSS J025346.36-072343.6 G 02 53 46.365 -07 23 43.61           ~ 2 0
25 PB 6923 Sy1 02 54 26.1142885944 -00 41 22.160643936   17.56 17.57     ~ 20 0
26 SDSS J030149.01-005257.4 EmG 03 01 49.026 -00 52 57.39           ~ 11 0
27 [PBT2001] SBSG 0335-052 W G 03 37 38.40 -05 02 37.5   19.14     18.85 ~ 107 1
28 SBSG 0335-052B G 03 37 44.04 -05 02 40.2   16.77 16.65   16.79 ~ 185 1
29 UGC 3174 GiC 04 48 34.50 +00 14 30.0   14.7   13.9 14.4 ~ 66 0
30 UGC 3647 AG? 07 04 50.94 +56 31 13.8   16.0       ~ 37 0
31 UGC 3672 AG? 07 06 27.336 +30 19 23.61   17       ~ 40 0
32 UGC 3974 G 07 41 56.3059298112 +16 48 07.451632188   15.4       ~ 225 0
33 UGC 4117 AG? 07 57 25.948 +35 56 22.05   15.5       ~ 32 0
34 UGC 4305 IG 08 19 04.9864630512 +70 43 13.086910452 12.06 11.72 11.39 11.11   ~ 768 2
35 LEDA 2790884 bCG 08 25 55.5166210656 +35 32 31.833368556   18.2       ~ 120 1
36 SDSS J082718.07+460203.0 G 08 27 18.069 +46 02 02.98           ~ 2 0
37 UGC 4483 GiG 08 37 03.00 +69 46 31.0 15.70 15.46 14.98 14.89   ~ 302 0
38 Mrk 627 EmG 08 46 34.446 +36 26 21.48   15.6       ~ 26 0
39 LEDA 2790886 EmG 08 49 40.3214491272 +35 11 38.002195500   19.0       ~ 10 0
40 LEDA 1177519 H2G 08 59 20.8443158808 +00 51 42.235412688           ~ 16 0
41 SDSS J091028.77+071117.9 H2G 09 10 28.7687526264 +07 11 18.149714808           ~ 8 0
42 SDSS J091159.43+313535.9 AG? 09 11 59.434 +31 35 35.92           ~ 14 0
43 Mrk 104 Sy1 09 16 45.5160392472 +53 26 34.300942764   14.7       ~ 44 0
44 MCG+09-15-115 G 09 17 46.325 +53 17 33.09   16       ~ 8 0
45 Mrk 1416 AG? 09 20 55.93 +52 34 07.2   17.0       ~ 59 0
46 LB 555 EmG 09 30 06.4773062016 +60 26 53.169485316   17.0       ~ 36 0
47 Mrk 116 PaG 09 34 02.1 +55 14 25           ~ 1104 1
48 LEDA 27591 SBG 09 40 12.843 +29 35 30.30   16.32 16.08     ~ 57 0
49 LEDA 27886 QSO 09 44 17.101 +54 11 28.83   19.5       ~ 71 0
50 Mrk 22 Sy1 09 49 30.3096198376 +55 34 46.971972356   15.7       ~ 71 0
51 SDSS J095241.42+020758.1 H2G 09 52 41.426 +02 07 58.14           ~ 7 0
52 UGC 5340 AG? 09 56 46.047 +28 49 43.77 14.82 14.74 14.59 14.55   ~ 227 1
53 NAME Sextans B H2G 10 00 00.8217342072 +05 20 09.533389560 12.77 12.25 11.89 11.71   ~ 528 0
54 NAME M81 dwB LSB 10 05 30.45024 +70 21 51.4253 15.95 15.56 15.09 14.87   ~ 203 1
55 LEDA 29998 EmG 10 16 24.516 +37 54 45.96   16.5       ~ 52 0
56 Mrk 140 AG? 10 16 28.2135145968 +45 19 17.164289028   15.0       ~ 48 0
57 SDSS J103137.27+043422.0 GiP 10 31 37.2791738640 +04 34 22.224457776           ~ 7 0
58 Mrk 1434 SBG 10 34 10.155 +58 03 49.13   16.5   16.54   ~ 73 0
59 LEDA 2302764 EmG 10 36 25.010 +47 41 53.69   18.5       ~ 16 0
60 LEDA 2336386 G 10 40 42.852 +49 12 23.21   17.0       ~ 13 0
61 SDSS J104400.05+035305.3 * 10 44 00.057 +03 53 05.32           ~ 1 0
62 SDSS J104456.00+004433.5 H2G 10 44 56.0207339952 +00 44 33.544947264           ~ 3 0
63 Z 10-41 AG? 10 52 48.6343718040 +00 02 04.035314544   16.0   15.6 15.5 ~ 23 0
64 LEDA 2678872 Sy1 10 57 41.9696561712 +65 35 39.903886320           ~ 10 0
65 LEDA 2147507 EmG 11 02 09.80160 +39 18 45.3960   18.20 17.7     ~ 11 0
66 MCG+10-16-059 AG? 11 05 53.6921585616 +60 22 28.499349252   16       ~ 24 0
67 BFW78 9 EmG 11 10 57.9 +09 36 34           ~ 7 0
68 NAME Arp's Galaxy AG? 11 19 34.344 +51 30 12.17   17.3       ~ 71 0
69 NAME NGC 3640 companion G 11 21 51.34 +03 24 17.4           ~ 13 0
70 SDSS J112526.75+654607.2 H2G 11 25 26.750 +65 46 07.17           ~ 5 0
71 Mrk 1446 H2G 11 27 32.6498672448 +53 54 54.508878252   16.5       ~ 29 0
72 [VV2003c] J112743.0+641001 Sy1 11 27 42.9585182424 +64 10 01.431611796     18.12     ~ 5 0
73 MCG+10-17-011 AG? 11 32 02.6164558680 +57 22 36.292387908   17       ~ 59 1
74 [VV2003c] J113341.2+634926 Sy1 11 33 41.2728875376 +63 49 26.069908260     18.33     ~ 6 0
75 2MASX J11481815-0138230 Sy1 11 48 18.153 -01 38 23.05   15.6   15.847   ~ 31 0
76 LEDA 37102 Sy1 11 51 33.3537570144 -02 22 21.893502576   17       ~ 167 0
77 Mrk 1307 Sy1 11 52 37.19 -02 28 09.9   14.79   14.09 14.9 ~ 171 0
78 2dFGRS TGN311Z206 Sy1 11 52 47.5102092912 -00 40 07.665791232   18   17.188   ~ 45 0
79 LEDA 2815986 AG? 12 02 02.4750603336 +54 15 51.049196784   18.0       ~ 76 0
80 LEDA 2501589 AG? 12 08 28.1896864416 +55 25 25.797650880   17.0       ~ 31 0
81 Mrk 1313 Sy1 12 12 14.7430689744 +00 04 20.530354908   17.56 17.40     ~ 77 0
82 LEDA 39055 EmG 12 14 02.4588226248 +53 45 17.525587212   18       ~ 83 0
83 MCG+01-31-030 GiP 12 15 18.322 +05 45 40.28   14.9       ~ 92 0
84 NGC 4228 SBG 12 15 39.174 +36 19 36.80 10.63 10.30 9.93 9.74   ~ 965 1
85 LEDA 2816013 AG? 12 25 05.438 +61 09 09.72   17.0       ~ 47 0
86 ESO 380-27 H2G 12 25 46.95 -36 14 00.7   17.47   16.52   ~ 100 1
87 NAME Virgo Cluster ClG 12 26 32.1 +12 43 24           ~ 6637 0
88 LEDA 42204 EmG 12 38 06.8792917776 +10 09 56.059792560   16.79       ~ 42 0
89 NAME CVn I dwA GiC 12 38 40.06 +32 46 00.5 16.91 16.66 16.73 16.62   ~ 232 0
90 2dFGRS TGN127Z083 EmG 12 41 59.3495588664 -03 40 02.598496572   18.722   18.044   ~ 13 0
91 UGC 8024 GiC 12 54 05.248 +27 08 58.67 14.37 14.23 13.95 13.84   ~ 592 1
92 UGC 8091 H2G 12 58 40.1930636208 +14 13 00.739589628 15.24 15.16 14.98 14.81   ~ 463 0
93 2dFGRS TGN327Z109 LSB 13 02 40.79 +01 04 26.8   18   16.818   ~ 35 0
94 KISS F1312-2143 EmG 13 13 16.4 +44 02 30           ~ 11 0
95 UGCA 357 AG? 13 26 13.800 +37 46 14.67   17       ~ 26 0
96 UGC 8651 AG? 13 39 53.75 +40 44 25.3 15.37 14.56 14.20 14.10   ~ 155 0
97 Mrk 1480 H2G 13 42 51.8581668336 +52 42 30.386681784   16.5       ~ 29 0
98 SDSS J135030.82+622649.0 H2G 13 50 30.7888519248 +62 26 49.129518084           ~ 4 0
99 2dFGRS TGN338Z246 Sy1 13 52 36.861 +00 01 20.98   18       ~ 20 0
100 UGC 9128 AG? 14 15 57.0834 +23 03 29.871 15.40 14.77 14.41 14.32   ~ 283 0
101 MCG+07-29-060 QSO 14 17 01.716 +43 30 13.52   15.6       ~ 172 0
102 UGC 9240 AG? 14 24 43.21 +44 31 41.8 14.24 13.54 13.17 13.07   ~ 200 0
103 LEDA 99823 AG? 14 25 24.61 +51 33 16.6   17.0       ~ 21 0
104 Z 247-36 AG? 14 30 12.2086044216 +45 32 32.369487468   15.2       ~ 29 0
105 ECO 7278 H2G 14 30 53.5113099312 +00 27 46.303249140           ~ 15 0
106 UGC 9497 H2G 14 44 12.8032800372 +42 37 43.773570223   16.0       ~ 82 0
107 LEDA 2414734 AG? 14 54 42.9226962624 +52 25 44.965384068   17.0       ~ 20 0
108 SDSS J153704.18+551550.5 H2G 15 37 04.1703489192 +55 15 50.657550372           ~ 6 0
109 UGC 9992 AG? 15 41 47.85 +67 15 15.3 15.71 15.22 14.81 14.44   ~ 88 0
110 LEDA 101538 H2G 16 16 23.5420809528 +47 02 02.261620176   16.9       ~ 20 1
111 SDSS J165730.04+384123.2 EmG 16 57 30.034 +38 41 23.23   17.1       ~ 7 0
112 LEDA 2790946 EmG 17 05 45.3265183560 +43 28 49.507838940   18.1       ~ 13 0
113 SDSS J171236.63+321633.4 EmG 17 12 36.6269544336 +32 16 33.232622988           ~ 12 0
114 Mrk 894 G 17 18 28.1 +30 10 43   16.5       ~ 9 0
115 NGC 6822 G 19 44 56.199 -14 47 51.29   18 8.1     ~ 1562 0
116 SDSS J210455.31-003522.3 G 21 04 55.310 -00 35 22.38           ~ 31 0
117 [GPM2009] J2119-0732 G 21 19 42.381 -07 32 24.39           ~ 4 0
118 SDSS J213658.81+041404.0 bCG 21 36 58.82310 +04 14 04.0999           ~ 12 0
119 NAME Kinman Dwarf bCG 22 30 36.7959714600 -00 06 36.924915456 16.85 17.35 16.87   16.65 ~ 65 2
120 LEDA 71137 G 23 20 35.1835589520 -00 52 51.225894516   18       ~ 14 0
121 NAME PegDIG G 23 28 35.2 +14 44 35 13.85 13.16 12.52     ~ 474 1
122 UGC 12713 AG? 23 38 14.758 +30 42 33.24   15.1       ~ 56 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2010MNRAS.406.1238E and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu