2018MNRAS.474.2116D


Query : 2018MNRAS.474.2116D

2018MNRAS.474.2116D - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 474, 2116-2128 (2018/February-3)

The initial masses of the red supergiant progenitors to Type II supernovae.

DAVIES B. and BEASOR E.R.

Abstract (from CDS):

There are a growing number of nearby supernovae (SNe) for which the progenitor star is detected in archival pre-explosion imaging. From these images it is possible to measure the progenitor's brightness a few years before explosion, and ultimately estimate its initial mass. Previous work has shown that II-P and II-L SNe have red supergiant (RSG) progenitors, and that the range of initial masses for these progenitors seems to be limited to <= 17 M. This is in contrast with the cut-off of 25-30 M predicted by evolutionary models, a result that is termed the 'red supergiant problem'. Here we investigate one particular source of systematic error present in converting pre-explosion photometry into an initial mass, which of the bolometric correction (BC) used to convert a single-band flux into a bolometric luminosity. We show, using star clusters, that RSGs evolve to later spectral types as they approach SN, which in turn causes the BC to become larger. Failure to account for this results in a systematic underestimate of a star's luminosity, and hence its initial mass. Using our empirically motivated BCs we reappraise the II-P and II-L SNe that have their progenitors detected in pre-explosion imaging. Fitting an initial mass function to these updated masses results in an increased upper mass cut-off of Mhi = 19.0+2.5–1.3 M, with a 95 per cent upper confidence limit of <27 M. Accounting for finite sample size effects and systematic uncertainties in the mass-luminosity relationship raises the cut-off to Mhi = 25 M (<33 M, 95 per cent confidence). We therefore conclude that there is currently no strong evidence for 'missing' high-mass progenitors to core-collapse SNe.

Abstract Copyright: © 2017 The Authors Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Royal Astronomical Society

Journal keyword(s): stars: evolution - stars: late-type - stars: massive - supergiants - supernovae: general

Simbad objects: 58

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 58
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 NAME SMC G 00 52 38.0 -72 48 01   2.79 2.2     ~ 11146 1
2 SN 2003gd SN* 01 36 42.65 +15 44 19.9     13.2     SNIIP 248 2
3 SN 2013ej SN* 01 36 48.16 +15 45 31.0           SNIIP 199 0
4 * chi Per * 02 18 04.5845635872 +57 30 58.759401204   7.036 6.0230     G7.0III 169 1
5 V* BU Per s*r 02 18 53.2915355976 +57 25 16.763048652 15.53 12.87 10.40     M4Ib 93 0
6 V* AD Per s*r 02 20 29.0035384536 +56 59 35.239755912 12.70 10.16 7.8490   7.1111 M3Iab 127 1
7 V* FZ Per s*r 02 20 59.6455018656 +57 09 29.964294288 12.75 10.20 7.9620   6.7185 M1Iab 114 0
8 Ass Per OB 1 As* 02 21 +57.6           ~ 174 1
9 V* SU Per s*r 02 22 06.8948309496 +56 36 14.893650072 13.86 11.57 9.40     M3-M4Iab 145 0
10 V* RS Per s*r 02 22 24.2955658080 +57 06 34.102933812 12.37 10.09 8.7680     M3.5IabFe-1 143 0
11 V* S Per s*r 02 22 51.7113133056 +58 35 11.422774248 13.22 10.55 7.90     M4.5-7Iae 376 0
12 V* V439 Per s*r 02 23 11.0656487832 +57 11 57.984565452 12.81 10.41 8.1650   6.8612 M0.5Iab 80 0
13 V* V403 Per s*r 02 23 24.1101297168 +57 12 43.045313724 13.32 10.81 8.4020 6.67 5.21 M0Iab 69 0
14 V* V441 Per s*r 02 25 21.8607402192 +57 26 14.130487320 13.07 10.61 8.22 6.09 4.29 M3Iab 83 0
15 SN 2012ec SN* 02 45 59.89 -07 34 25.0         22.32 SNIIP 73 3
16 V* W Per s*r 02 50 37.8929743824 +56 59 00.287654892 14.80 12.24 9.62 6.99 4.75 M3Iab-M5I 115 0
17 SN 2001du SN* 03 33 29.11 -36 08 32.5     14.0     SNIIP 54 1
18 NAME Perseus Cloud SFR 03 35.0 +31 13           ~ 1364 0
19 SN 1999em SN* 04 41 27.04 -02 51 45.2   13.79 13.7     SNIIP 674 1
20 SN 2009kr SN* 05 12 03.30 -15 41 52.2           SNII 82 1
21 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 17432 0
22 W61 8-67 s*r 05 41 44.0133813696 -69 12 02.710433232 14.823 14.234 13.106 12.07 11.12 K5Ia-Iab 18 0
23 SV* HV 6002 LP? 05 41 47.8574143416 -69 12 05.956606332 19.677 16.488 13.749   9.769 M1 19 0
24 W61 6-30 s*r 05 42 00.7170452688 -69 11 36.939733872 17.677 15.579 13.674 12.60 11.379 M2Iab 23 0
25 NGC 2100 Cl* 05 42 07.200 -69 12 26.99   9.6       ~ 189 0
26 SN 2006bc SN* 07 21 16.50 -68 59 57.3   17.6 16.0     SNIIP 48 1
27 SN 1999gi SN* 10 18 16.66 +41 26 28.2   14.8       SNIIP 235 1
28 SN 2012A SN* 10 25 07.39 +17 09 14.6           SNIIP 113 0
29 SN 2012aw SN* 10 43 53.735 +11 40 17.63       15   SNIIP 203 1
30 SN 2009md SN* 10 48 26.28 +12 32 02.8           SNIIP 66 2
31 SN 2009hd SN* 11 20 16.99 +12 58 46.3           SNII 62 1
32 SN 2007aa SN* 12 00 27.69 -01 04 51.6 16.9 16.4 5.8     SNIIP 66 1
33 SN 1999an SN* 12 01 10.57 +14 06 12.3     15     SNII 29 1
34 SN 2006ov SN* 12 21 55.30 +04 29 16.7     14.9     SNIIP 75 1
35 SN 2008cn SN* 12 40 55.66 -40 58 12.1           SNII 38 1
36 SN 2006my SN* 12 43 40.74 +16 23 14.1     15.3     SNIIP 58 1
37 SN 1999br SN* 13 00 41.80 +02 29 45.8     17.5     SNIIPp 165 1
38 SN 2005cs SN* 13 29 53.37 +47 10 28.2   14.5       SNIIP 408 1
39 SN 2004dg SN* 14 59 58.96 +01 53 25.6     17.1     SNIIP 36 1
40 SN 2004A SN* 16 43 01.90 +36 50 12.5     15.7     SNIIP 76 1
41 RSGC 1 OpC 18 37 58 -06 53.0           ~ 106 0
42 2MASS J18391838-0600383 s*r 18 39 18.3799841880 -06 00 38.338188588     19.70     M5I 8 0
43 2MASS J18391952-0559194 s*r 18 39 19.5126214032 -05 59 19.501141704     19.70     M3I 7 0
44 IRC -10447 s*r 18 39 19.6089504936 -06 00 40.750521660           M3I 20 0
45 Cl Stephenson 2 OpC 18 39 20 -06 01.7           ~ 93 0
46 2MASS J18392253-0600084 s*r 18 39 22.5351457392 -06 00 08.423272008         12.88 M1.5Iab 10 0
47 2MASS J18392397-0603072 s*r 18 39 23.9689009152 -06 03 07.355015064     20.24   13.20 M1Ia 7 0
48 Cl Stephenson 2 9 s*r 18 39 24.1073796768 -06 00 22.841980488         13.18 M1.5Iab 8 0
49 MSX6C G026.1903-00.0876 s*r 18 39 24.6071283792 -06 02 13.902820476     19.91 16.4 12.85 M5Iab 13 0
50 SN 2002hh SN* 20 34 44.29 +60 07 19.0     17.18     SNIIP 152 1
51 SN 2004et SN* 20 35 25.33 +60 07 17.7   12.88       SNIIP 489 1
52 Cl* NGC 7419 BNSW e s*r 22 54 01.2195146928 +60 47 41.723256804   17.379 13.920 12.823   M1.5Iab 18 0
53 Cl* NGC 7419 BNSW d s*r 22 54 16.0930465608 +60 49 28.996946328   14.34 12.86 11.89   M2Iab 13 0
54 NGC 7419 OpC 22 54 19.0 +60 48 50     13.0     ~ 106 0
55 Cl* NGC 7419 BNSW c s*r 22 54 22.6648756944 +60 48 31.553568108   16.49 12.91 11.89   M2Iab 10 0
56 Cl* NGC 7419 BNSW a s*r 22 54 30.4469918832 +60 47 50.578596024   16.44 13.05 12.00   M2Iab 19 0
57 V* MY Cep s*r 22 54 31.6975387464 +60 49 38.973030780   16.149 13.770 12.822   M7.5I 87 0
58 SN 2008bk SN* 23 57 50.42 -32 33 21.5           SNIIP 140 2

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2018MNRAS.474.2116D and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu