2015AJ....149..132B


Query : 2015AJ....149..132B

2015AJ....149..132B - Astron. J., 149, 132 (2015/April-0)

Hubble Space Telescope snapshot search for planetary nebulae in globular clusters of the Local Group.

BOND H.E.

Abstract (from CDS):

Single stars in ancient globular clusters (GCs) are believed incapable of producing planetary nebulae (PNs), because their post-asymptotic-giant-branch evolutionary timescales are slower than the dissipation timescales for PNs. Nevertheless, four PNs are known in Galactic GCs. Their existence likely requires more exotic evolutionary channels, including stellar mergers and common-envelope binary interactions. I carried out a snapshot imaging search with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) for PNs in bright Local Group GCs outside the Milky Way. I used a filter covering the 5007 Å nebular emission line of [O iii], and another one in the nearby continuum, to image 66 GCs. Inclusion of archival HST frames brought the total number of extragalactic GCs imaged at 5007 Å to 75, whose total luminosity slightly exceeds that of the entire Galactic GC system. I found no convincing PNs in these clusters, aside from one PN in a young M31 cluster misclassified as a GC, and two PNs at such large angular separations from an M31 GC that membership is doubtful. In a ground-based spectroscopic survey of 274 old GCs in M31, Jacoby et al. found three candidate PNs. My HST images of one of them suggest that the [O iii] emission actually arises from ambient interstellar medium rather than a PN; for the other two candidates, there are broadband archival UV HST images that show bright, blue point sources that are probably the PNs. In a literature search, I also identified five further PN candidates lying near old GCs in M31, for which follow-up observations are necessary to confirm their membership. The rates of incidence of PNs are similar, and small but nonzero, throughout the GCs of the Local Group.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): globular clusters: general - planetary nebulae: general - stars: AGB and post-AGB

Nomenclature: Tables 2, 3, 5: [B2015] M31 BNNNA-NN N=62, [B2015] NGC 147 HII-1 N=1.

CDS comments: In Table 3, FJ 4 is a probable misprint for MJ 5 (Ford M31 5 in SIMBAD).

Simbad objects: 177

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 177
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 [BHE2002] WLM 1 GlC 00 01 49.48 -15 27 30.7   16.64 16.06     ~ 23 0
2 NAME Wolf-Lundmark-Melotte G 00 01 57.9 -15 27 50   11.50 11.10 10.93   ~ 691 2
3 NAME Mackey-GC1 GlC 00 26 47.7578536272 +39 44 46.082343084     16.05   15.07 ~ 21 1
4 NGC 121 GlC 00 26 49.0 -71 32 10   11.2 11.24     ~ 311 0
5 2MASX J00302731+4136193 GlC 00 30 27.3168237696 +41 36 18.963573372     16.31   15.36 ~ 22 0
6 Bol 514 GlC 00 31 09.83 +37 54 00.0     16.28   14.68 ~ 42 0
7 NAME Mayall II GlC 00 32 46.5323801712 +39 34 40.504803060   14.564 13.807 13.208 12.684 ~ 389 1
8 NGC 147 GiG 00 33 12.120 +48 30 31.46   12.0 9.5     ~ 687 1
9 FJJ NGC 147 1 PN? 00 33 12.66 +48 28 18.1           ~ 6 0
10 FJJ NGC 147 III GlC 00 33 13.59 +48 28 48.6 17.7 17.6 17.0     ~ 6 0
11 FJJ NGC 147 II GlC 00 33 15.17 +48 27 23.2 17.5 17.1 16.5     ~ 5 0
12 NAME Mayall III GlC 00 33 33.7890475296 +39 31 18.763470120 16.750 16.482 15.807 15.325   ~ 55 0
13 LEDA 2068390 GlC 00 35 59.7358005048 +35 41 03.597283752     16.09   15.01 ~ 30 0
14 Bol 293 GlC 00 36 20.8643945520 +40 53 37.135021884 17.190 17.033 16.35 15.787 15.40 ~ 57 0
15 PN BoBn 1 PN 00 37 16.03 -13 42 58.6   16       ~ 131 1
16 MLA 47 EmO 00 38 04.30 +40 43 44.0     21.82     ~ 3 0
17 NGC 185 Sy2 00 38 57.9400026024 +48 20 15.035874648   9.10 9.2     ~ 800 1
18 Bol 311 GlC 00 39 33.7263390600 +40 31 14.621665512 16.338 16.209 15.362 14.803 14.39 ~ 81 0
19 Bol 312 GlC 00 39 40.1718715803 +40 57 02.463479887 16.680 16.274 15.571 16.155 14.160 ~ 46 1
20 [SCM2012b] HII031 HII 00 40 16.40 +40 43 23.9     23.71     ~ 4 0
21 Bol 5 GlC 00 40 20.3107323072 +40 43 58.299232188 16.880 16.552 15.529 14.895 14.400 ~ 63 0
22 Bol 327 GlC 00 40 24.101 +40 36 22.64 16.55 16.90 16.58 16.31 16.00 ~ 47 1
23 [MMD2006] 2052 PN 00 40 25.80 +40 37 06.4     22.65     ~ 3 0
24 NAME VDB 0 OpC 00 40 29.385 +40 36 15.20 14.957 14.94 15.288 15.056 14.701 ~ 44 2
25 Bol 8 GlC 00 40 30.2781445416 +41 16 08.785896780 18.160 17.660 16.560 16.210 15.510 ~ 43 0
26 [SCM2012b] PN046 PN 00 40 30.90 +40 36 54.2     20.65     ~ 6 0
27 Bol 19 GlC 00 40 52.5299628912 +41 18 53.489147724 16.360 15.940 14.98 14.310 13.740 ~ 53 0
28 [B2015] M31 B023-1 PN? 00 40 58.27 +41 14 16.8           ~ 1 0
29 Bol 338 GlC 00 40 58.871 +40 35 47.41 15.123 15.034 14.168 13.621 13.27 ~ 76 0
30 Bol 23 GlC 00 41 01.151 +41 13 45.41 16.040 15.400 14.17 13.560 12.570 ~ 91 0
31 Bol 27 GlC 00 41 14.5288661472 +40 55 50.974329576 16.669 16.486 15.642 15.104 14.55 ~ 65 0
32 Bol 37 GlC 00 41 34.9868411928 +41 14 55.086295416 19.891 18.749 16.849 15.428 14.190 ~ 64 0
33 [SCM2012b] PN107 PN 00 41 37.50 +41 15 10.7     22.19     ~ 4 0
34 Bol 41 * 00 41 40.81 +41 14 45.5 19.552 19.240 18.542 18.088 17.553 ~ 29 0
35 Bol 343 GlC 00 41 43.1127886392 +40 12 22.378121748 17.230 17.080 16.69 15.910 15.42 ~ 71 0
36 Bol 58 GlC 00 41 53.0027897448 +40 47 09.670417656 15.986 15.776 14.967 14.474 14.03 ~ 79 0
37 Bol 61 GlC 00 42 00.1325402352 +41 29 35.739624372 18.490 17.870 16.721 15.959 15.120 ~ 45 0
38 Bol 63 GlC 00 42 00.8663431920 +41 29 09.534752664 17.416 16.806 15.650 14.885 14.080 ~ 46 0
39 [B2015] M31 B063-1 PN? 00 42 06.30 +41 29 29.5           ~ 1 0
40 Bol 75 GlC 00 42 08.8044831960 +41 20 21.377716368 18.733 18.385 17.413 16.809 16.329 ~ 31 0
41 [MMD2006] 759 EmO 00 42 09.10 +41 20 22.8     22.57     ~ 2 0
42 Bol 80 GlC 00 42 12.3837262320 +41 19 00.636633192 19.288 18.663 17.442 16.626 15.939 ~ 33 0
43 Bol 82 GlC 00 42 15.8394998856 +41 01 14.308375260 18.082 16.972 15.465 14.497 13.630 ~ 79 0
44 [B2015] M31 B086-3 PN? 00 42 16.99 +41 14 02.3           ~ 1 0
45 Bol 84 GlC 00 42 17.4320283312 +41 18 55.621005948 20.134 19.401 18.155 17.343 16.688 ~ 21 0
46 [B2015] M31 B086-1 PN? 00 42 18.62 +41 14 08.8           ~ 1 0
47 Bol 86 GlC 00 42 18.6515838696 +41 14 01.999584816 15.985 15.899 15.131 14.661 13.920 ~ 76 0
48 MLA 481 PN? 00 42 19.03 +41 14 02.6           ~ 2 0
49 [SCM2012b] PN170 PN 00 42 21.20 +41 00 54.0     22.33     ~ 5 0
50 Bol 96 GlC 00 42 26.080 +41 19 14.79 18.796 17.863 16.635 15.857 15.188 ~ 67 0
51 [MMD2006] 534 EmO 00 42 30.70 +41 30 24.6     23.23     ~ 2 0
52 Bol 105 GlC 00 42 30.7600675272 +41 30 27.336946860 18.421 18.079 17.168 16.580 16.059 ~ 32 0
53 Bol 110 GlC 00 42 33.1042029024 +41 03 28.347878700 16.430 16.036 15.163 14.619 14.000 ~ 71 0
54 Bol 115 GlC 00 42 34.4029603032 +41 14 01.942644156 17.844 17.058 16.042 15.408 14.81 ~ 64 0
55 Ford M 31 54 PN 00 42 37.08 +41 14 35.5     20.53     ~ 9 0
56 [KLG2007] GC1 52 GlC 00 42 37.3230545496 +41 50 53.621763828 19.37 19.14 18.53 18.17 17.83 ~ 6 0
57 Ford M 31 71 PN 00 42 37.49 +41 14 35.0     21.59     ~ 6 0
58 [MMD2006] 2598 EmO 00 42 37.5765655056 +41 50 55.768662420     24.40     ~ 2 0
59 ACH 5 GlC 00 42 37.98 +41 15 58.9 19.00 18.180 17.98 16.990 17.17 ~ 28 0
60 Ford M 31 35 PN 00 42 38.27 +41 15 33.8     21.47     ~ 7 0
61 Ford M 31 143 PN 00 42 38.36 +41 14 27.7     23.13     ~ 7 0
62 Ford M 31 55 PN 00 42 38.38 +41 14 34.6     21.37     ~ 7 0
63 Ford M 31 70 PN 00 42 38.96 +41 14 56.5     22.09     ~ 5 0
64 Ford M 31 65 PN 00 42 39.39 +41 14 17.6     22.04     ~ 5 0
65 Ford M 31 18 PN 00 42 39.72 +41 15 36.6     20.82     ~ 8 0
66 CXOM31 J004239.9+411547 PN 00 42 39.74 +41 15 49.2     20.76     ~ 17 0
67 Ford M 31 66 PN 00 42 40.07 +41 14 38.3     22.08     ~ 5 0
68 Ford M 31 334 PN 00 42 40.16 +41 15 32.9           ~ 3 0
69 Ford M 31 159 PN 00 42 40.20 +41 13 25.3     22.43     ~ 4 0
70 Ford M 31 160 PN 00 42 40.21 +41 13 51.0     22.83     ~ 6 0
71 Ford M 31 333 PN 00 42 40.27 +41 15 44.3           ~ 3 0
72 Ford M 31 181 PN 00 42 40.33 +41 14 10.0     21.84     ~ 6 0
73 Ford M 31 56 PN 00 42 40.8304418218 +41 14 09.990137223     20.94     ~ 10 0
74 Ford M 31 141 PN 00 42 41.34 +41 14 07.4     22.19     ~ 5 0
75 Bol 124 GlC 00 42 41.43 +41 15 23.9 16.153 15.589 14.73 14.060 13.74 ~ 66 0
76 Ford M 31 57 PN 00 42 42.10 +41 14 09.5     21.04     ~ 7 0
77 2MASS J00424214+4114241 PN 00 42 42.150 +41 14 24.12     22.51     ~ 5 0
78 Ford M 31 5 PN 00 42 42.34 +41 15 53.7     21.07     ~ 8 0
79 Ford M 31 99 PN 00 42 42.43 +41 13 56.5     22.11     ~ 5 0
80 CXOM31 J004242.4+411553 PN 00 42 42.464 +41 15 53.82           ~ 10 0
81 [B2015] M31 B127-22 PN? 00 42 42.62 +41 13 33.8           ~ 1 0
82 Ford M 31 73 PN 00 42 42.90 +41 15 20.2     22.31     ~ 5 0
83 Ford M 31 19 PN 00 42 43.02 +41 15 32.2     22.33     ~ 5 0
84 Ford M 31 20 PN 00 42 43.05 +41 15 36.8     21.75     ~ 6 0
85 Ford M 31 139 PN 00 42 43.07 +41 14 09.3     22.61     ~ 5 0
86 Ford M 31 7 PN 00 42 43.27 +41 15 56.5     21.24     ~ 6 0
87 Ford M 31 319 PN 00 42 43.80 +41 15 39.3           ~ 3 0
88 Ford M 31 8 PN 00 42 43.86 +41 16 01.1     19.96     ~ 8 0
89 M31N 2006-11b No* 00 42 44.05 +41 15 02.0           ~ 4 1
90 M 31 AGN 00 42 44.330 +41 16 07.50 4.86 4.36 3.44     ~ 12651 1
91 Ford M 31 581 PN 00 42 44.38 +41 15 05.3     22.92     ~ 3 0
92 Bol 127 GlC 00 42 44.52 +41 14 41.5 15.80 15.200 14.42 13.800 13.29 ~ 61 0
93 [JSD2015] AP 6039 GlC 00 42 44.7717228792 +41 14 44.145868128 18.366 18.089 17.200   17.01 ~ 27 0
94 Ford M 31 74 PN 00 42 44.88 +41 15 21.0     21.63     ~ 7 0
95 Ford M 31 574 PN 00 42 44.97 +41 16 04.1           ~ 3 0
96 CXOM31 J004245.0+411523 PN 00 42 45.15 +41 15 23.6     21.04     ~ 15 0
97 Ford M 31 9 PN 00 42 45.15 +41 16 05.4           ~ 7 0
98 Ford M 31 323 PN 00 42 45.24 +41 15 29.6     22.16     ~ 5 0
99 [B2015] M31 B127-37 PN? 00 42 45.76 +41 16 01.2           ~ 1 0
100 Ford M 31 633 PN 00 42 45.78 +41 17 35.2     22.69     ~ 3 0
101 Ford M 31 454 PN 00 42 45.79 +41 16 01.5           ~ 3 0
102 2MASS J00424589+4115149 PN 00 42 45.8396551248 +41 15 15.238067832     21.63     ~ 6 0
103 [B2015] M31 B127-38 PN? 00 42 45.85 +41 16 01.3           ~ 1 0
104 NAME PB-in7 GlC 00 42 46.0811940504 +41 17 36.209244228 20.30 18.975 18.093 17.560 17.48 ~ 28 0
105 Ford M 31 22 PN 00 42 46.27 +41 15 23.0     22.32     ~ 4 0
106 Ford M 31 72 PN 00 42 46.34 +41 15 46.3     21.45     ~ 7 0
107 Ford M 31 10 PN 00 42 46.66 +41 16 09.7     21.26     ~ 8 0
108 M31GC J004248+411601 GlC 00 42 48.18 +41 16 00.6 20.17 18.455 18.097   17.57 ~ 16 0
109 [JSD2015] AP 7231 GlC 00 42 48.5413273368 +41 15 47.629243872 18.87 18.222 17.296 17.290 17.18 ~ 23 0
110 Bol 530 GlC 00 42 50.307 +41 25 12.40 17.910 18.624 18.541 18.638 18.721 ~ 8 0
111 Bol 132 GlC 00 42 51.4256716296 +41 15 40.646673648 19.82 18.666 17.561 16.886 16.52 ~ 30 0
112 Bol 264 GlC 00 42 53.19 +41 16 14.4 18.63 18.583 17.713 17.172 16.97 ~ 24 0
113 Bol 158 GlC 00 43 14.3953843272 +41 07 21.141017796 15.900 15.560 14.65 14.150 13.550 ~ 117 1
114 Bol D97 GlC 00 43 16.74 +41 06 33.4 19.649 19.254 18.410 17.830 17.145 ~ 15 1
115 Bol 171 GlC 00 43 25.6003962624 +41 15 37.095704604 16.795 16.192 15.217 14.635 14.07 ~ 73 0
116 Bol 174 GlC 00 43 30.2984835048 +41 38 56.239256508 16.653 16.280 15.363 14.709 14.057 ~ 43 0
117 Bol 179 GlC 00 43 31.1069226792 +41 18 14.612214636 16.449 16.162 15.316 14.800 14.43 ~ 52 0
118 [B2015] M31 B179-1 EmO 00 43 32.60 +41 17 20.7     23.11   22.423 ~ 4 0
119 [SCM2012b] PN261 PN 00 43 32.70 +41 18 32.8     21.28     ~ 5 0
120 [KLG2007] GC1 70 G 00 43 39.74 +41 29 16.3 21.012 20.672 19.615 18.914 18.169 ~ 6 0
121 [SCM2012b] PN274 PN 00 43 40.10 +41 36 01.5     22.84     ~ 4 0
122 Ford M 31 274 PN 00 43 41.60 +41 28 02.0     22.14   24.251 ~ 7 0
123 [B2015] M31 B472-2 PN 00 43 43.30 +41 27 30.5     22.87   22.535 ~ 6 0
124 Bol 192 GlC 00 43 44.5150190232 +41 37 26.544097632 18.529 18.491 18.186 18.013 17.738 ~ 23 1
125 Bol 193 GlC 00 43 45.4998657576 +41 36 57.605146668 16.746 16.097 15.193 14.565 14.18 ~ 89 0
126 Bol D103 GlC 00 43 47.5321347840 +41 27 07.993225044 18.98 18.550 17.694 17.122 16.498 ~ 23 0
127 Bol 472 GlC 00 43 48.4211786904 +41 26 53.107014732 16.083 15.875 15.092 14.562 14.042 ~ 37 0
128 [B2015] M31 B193-2 PN? 00 43 49.91 +41 37 34.3           ~ 1 0
129 MLA 998 PN 00 44 27.50 +41 22 29.3     22.50   24.859 ~ 6 0
130 Bol 225 GlC 00 44 29.5618369896 +41 21 35.714596284 15.50 15.000 14.220 13.679 13.02 ~ 134 0
131 [B2015] M31 B225-2 EmO 00 44 31.00 +41 22 26.0     23.10   22.199 ~ 5 0
132 Bol 366 GlC 00 44 46.6310290224 +42 03 50.257820304 16.946 16.888 16.176 15.718 15.072 ~ 41 0
133 Bol 477 GlC 00 45 08.3248768344 +41 39 37.862863668 18.610 18.645 18.46 18.124 17.819 ~ 27 1
134 [B2015] M31 B477-1 PN? 00 45 08.41 +41 39 38.4           ~ 2 0
135 Bol 373 GlC 00 45 41.8461749256 +41 45 33.477770556 16.796 16.378 15.475 14.917 14.46 ~ 60 0
136 BA 4-20 GlC 00 45 44.3084142624 +41 57 27.725207904 19.273 18.900 17.984 17.406 16.749 ~ 16 0
137 [AMB2011] HII 3691 HII 00 45 44.60 +41 57 27.0     21.99     ~ 4 0
138 Bol 480 GlC 00 45 45.55 +41 45 52.5 18.665 18.560 18.139 17.892 17.492 ~ 27 1
139 Bol 379 GlC 00 45 58.8308321424 +40 42 31.402542528 17.460 17.032 16.183 15.560 14.936 ~ 75 0
140 Bol 384 GlC 00 46 21.9315533736 +40 16 59.645958420 17.370 16.743 15.752 15.260 14.564 ~ 64 0
141 Bol 386 GlC 00 46 27.0143614272 +42 01 52.743069552 16.554 16.355 15.541 14.997 14.435 ~ 91 0
142 [B2015] M31 B386-1 PN? 00 46 30.45 +42 01 09.6           ~ 1 0
143 Bol 405 GlC 00 49 39.7996917432 +41 35 29.776121412 16.220 15.930 15.195 14.656   ~ 65 0
144 Bol 407 GlC 00 50 09.9648082056 +41 41 01.034928888 17.630 16.953 16.053 15.400 14.830 ~ 58 0
145 NAME SMC G 00 52 38.0 -72 48 01   2.79 2.2     ~ 11150 1
146 [SSA2010] 1458 GlC 01 33 45.10 +30 47 46.7 17.210 17.081 16.298 15.823 15.311 ~ 38 0
147 M 33 GiG 01 33 50.8965749232 +30 39 36.630403128 6.17 6.27 5.72     ~ 5839 1
148 [MKK98] M 33 33 GlC 01 34 02.8654267368 +30 43 20.688279852 17.163 17.126 16.391 15.936 15.476 ~ 9 0
149 CBF 117 Cl* 01 34 07.28 +30 38 29.5 19.074 19.304 18.790 18.367 17.887 ~ 10 0
150 NAME Fornax H2 GlC 02 38 44.24 -34 48 30.5   14.5       ~ 92 0
151 NAME Fornax H3 GlC 02 39 48.16 -34 15 28.6   13.59       ~ 124 0
152 NAME Fornax Dwarf Spheroidal G 02 39 59.3 -34 26 57   9.02 7.4     ~ 1743 1
153 NAME Fornax H5 GlC 02 42 21.111 -34 06 05.80   14.5       ~ 99 0
154 NAME Magellanic Clouds GrG 03 00 -71.0           ~ 7067 0
155 NGC 1399 BiC 03 38 29.083 -35 27 02.67 11.05 9.74 9.59 8.12   ~ 1570 1
156 NGC 1466 GlC 03 44 32.71 -71 40 18.0   11.6 11.59     ~ 162 0
157 NGC 1786 Cl* 04 59 07.470 -67 44 45.44   10.1       ~ 146 0
158 NGC 1835 Cl* 05 05 09.210 -69 24 20.96   11.314 10.596     ~ 166 0
159 NGC 1916 Cl* 05 18 37.87 -69 24 22.9   11.16 10.38     ~ 91 0
160 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 17437 0
161 NGC 2005 Cl* 05 30 08.500 -69 45 14.42   12.30 11.57     ~ 94 0
162 NGC 2019 Cl* 05 31 56.48 -70 09 32.5   10.9 10.86     ~ 122 0
163 NGC 2210 GlC 06 11 31.296 -69 07 17.04   10.9 10.94     ~ 187 0
164 Cl Ruprecht 12 OpC 07 07.3 -28 13           ~ 15 0
165 Cl Ruprecht 14 OpC 07 14 52 -31 21.6           ~ 9 0
166 M 49 Sy2 12 29 46.8 +08 00 01   13.21 12.17     ~ 2094 2
167 M 87 AGN 12 30 49.42338414 +12 23 28.0436859 10.16 9.59 8.63   7.49 ~ 7197 3
168 ESO 520-21 GlC 17 43 42.20 -26 13 21.0           ~ 178 0
169 NGC 6441 GlC 17 50 13.06 -37 03 05.2           ~ 884 0
170 PN GJJC 1 PN 18 36 22.820 -23 55 18.26       13.52 12.44 ~ 97 0
171 M 22 GlC 18 36 23.94 -23 54 17.1           ~ 1379 0
172 PN A66 58 PN 19 18 20.476 +01 46 59.62           [WC4] 316 0
173 [H25] VII Cl* 19 44 55.77 -14 48 56.2   16.68 15.85     ~ 23 0
174 NGC 6822 G 19 44 56.199 -14 47 51.29   18 8.1     ~ 1562 0
175 M 15 GlC 21 29 58.33 +12 10 01.2           ~ 3140 0
176 PN Ps 1 PN 21 29 59.3972661392 +12 10 26.275343735   13.39 14.06     sdO 287 0
177 NAME Local Group GrG ~ ~           ~ 8392 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2015AJ....149..132B and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu