2010ApJS..187..495L


Query : 2010ApJS..187..495L

2010ApJS..187..495L - Astrophys. J., Suppl. Ser., 187, 495-559 (2010/April-0)

The Chandra ACIS survey of M33: X-ray, optical, and radio properties of the supernova remnants.

LONG K.S., BLAIR W.P., WINKLER P.F., BECKER R.H., GAETZ T.J., GHAVAMIAN P., HELFAND D.J., HUGHES J.P., KIRSHNER R.P., KUNTZ K.D., McNEIL E.K., PANNUTI T.G., PLUCINSKY P.P., SAUL D., TULLMANN R. and WILLIAMS B.

Abstract (from CDS):

M33 contains a large number of emission nebulae identified as supernova remnants (SNRs) based on the high [S II]:Hα ratios characteristic of shocked gas. Using Chandra data from the ChASeM33 survey with a 0.35-2 keV sensitivity of ∼2x1034 erg/s, we have detected 82 of 137 SNR candidates, yielding confirmation of (or at least strongly support for) their SNR identifications. This provides the largest sample of remnants detected at optical and X-ray wavelengths in any galaxy, including the Milky Way. A spectral analysis of the seven X-ray brightest SNRs reveals that two, G98-31 and G98-35, have spectra that appear to indicate enrichment by ejecta from core-collapse supernova explosions. In general, the X-ray-detected SNRs have soft X-ray spectra compared to the vast majority of sources detected along the line of sight to M33. It is unlikely that there are any other undiscovered thermally dominated X-ray SNRs with luminosities in excess of ∼4x1035 erg/s in the portions of M33 covered by the ChASeM33 survey. We have used a combination of new and archival optical and radio observations to attempt to better understand why some objects are detected as X-ray sources and others are not. We have also developed a morphological classification scheme for the optically identified SNRs and discussed the efficacy of this scheme as a predictor of X-ray detectability. Finally, we have compared the SNRs found in M33 to those that have been observed in the Galaxy and the Magellanic Clouds. There are no close analogs of Cas A, Kepler's SNR, Tycho's SNR, or the Crab Nebula in the regions of M33 surveyed, but we have found an X-ray source with a power-law spectrum coincident with a small-diameter radio source that may be the first pulsar-wind nebula recognized in M33.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: individual: M33 - galaxies: ISM - ISM: supernova remnants - radio continuum: galaxies

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJS/187/495): table3.dat table4.dat>

Nomenclature: Table 3: [LBW2010] NNN (Nos 1-137).

Status at CDS : All or part of tables of objects could be ingested in SIMBAD with priority 2.

Simbad objects: 203

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 203
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 SN 1572A SN* 00 25 21.5 +64 08 27           B8 1188 1
2 M 31 AGN 00 42 44.330 +41 16 07.50 4.86 4.36 3.44     ~ 12650 1
3 NAME SMC G 00 52 38.0 -72 48 01   2.79 2.2     ~ 11149 1
4 [LBW2010] 1 bub 01 32 30.60 +30 27 41.0           ~ 11 1
5 [DGG95] 48 SNR 01 32 31.50 +30 35 31.0           ~ 11 0
6 M33SNR 3 bub 01 32 42.50 +30 20 57.0           ~ 10 1
7 [LBW2010] 4 SNR 01 32 44.83 +30 22 14.6           ~ 7 0
8 [LBW2010] 5 SNR 01 32 46.46 +30 34 39.0           ~ 10 0
9 [LBW2010] 6 SR? 01 32 52.76 +30 38 12.6           ~ 6 0
10 [LBW2010] 7 SR? 01 32 53.36 +30 48 23.1           ~ 6 0
11 SNR B013004+30226 SNR 01 32 53.40 +30 37 56.9           ~ 13 0
12 [LBW2010] 9 SNR 01 32 54.10 +30 25 31.8           ~ 7 0
13 SNR B013007+30252 SNR 01 32 55.90 +30 40 41.0           ~ 21 0
14 SNR B013008+30241 SNR 01 32 57.10 +30 39 26.7     14.3     ~ 30 0
15 [LBW2010] 12 HII 01 33 00.15 +30 30 46.2           ~ 6 0
16 [LBW2010] 13 SNR 01 33 00.35 +30 44 07.2           ~ 13 0
17 [LBW2010] 14 SNR 01 33 00.67 +30 30 59.3           ~ 9 0
18 [LBW2010] 15 SNR 01 33 01.51 +30 30 49.6           ~ 9 0
19 [LBW2010] 16 SR? 01 33 02.93 +30 32 29.6           ~ 6 0
20 ChASeM33 47 s?r 01 33 03.5745954024 +30 39 03.906915624 19.275 19.874 19.447 19.062 18.458 ~ 10 0
21 [LBW2010] 17 SNR 01 33 03.60 +30 31 21.0           ~ 12 0
22 SNR B013015+30245 SNR 01 33 03.96 +30 39 53.2           ~ 33 0
23 M33SNR 16 HII 01 33 07.55 +30 42 52.5           ~ 8 1
24 [LBW2010] 20 SR? 01 33 08.98 +30 26 58.9           ~ 7 0
25 SNR B013021+30270 SNR 01 33 10.08 +30 42 22.1           ~ 16 0
26 SNR B013021+30241 SNR 01 33 10.10 +30 39 31.0           ~ 16 0
27 SNR B013022+30244 SNR 01 33 11.13 +30 39 43.9           ~ 24 0
28 SNR B013022+30190 SNR 01 33 11.30 +30 34 22.0           ~ 17 0
29 SNR B013022+30233 SNR 01 33 11.80 +30 38 41.5   18.8 18.80     ~ 40 1
30 VGHC 2-22 HII 01 33 12.188 +30 38 47.14           ~ 80 0
31 IC 131 HII 01 33 15.0 +30 45 09   12.52       ~ 63 0
32 [HS80] B100 WR* 01 33 15.169 +30 53 19.64 17.60 18.28 18.45     ~ 32 1
33 BCLMP 623 HII 01 33 15.9 +30 53 02     12.2     ~ 87 0
34 IC 133 HII 01 33 15.9 +30 53 02     12.2     ~ 86 0
35 [LBW2010] 26 SR? 01 33 16.73 +30 46 10.3           ~ 6 0
36 [LBW2010] 27 SNR 01 33 17.40 +30 31 27.0           ~ 11 0
37 [LBW2010] 28 bub 01 33 18.80 +30 27 04.4           ~ 6 0
38 [LBW2010] 29 SR? 01 33 18.94 +30 46 51.9           ~ 6 0
39 [LBW2010] 30 SNR 01 33 21.64 +30 31 31.1           ~ 9 0
40 [LBW2010] 31 SNR 01 33 22.70 +30 27 03.0           ~ 12 0
41 SNR B013035+30108 SNR 01 33 23.86 +30 26 13.4           ~ 23 0
42 [LBW2010] 33 SNR 01 33 26.70 +30 47 48.0           ~ 12 0
43 [LBW2010] 34 SNR 01 33 28.11 +30 31 35.3   20.59 20.83     ~ 20 0
44 [HS80] B133 s*b 01 33 28.9563601920 +30 47 44.000454012 15.715 16.677 16.742 16.737 16.756 B2.5Ia 33 0
45 SNR B013040+30269 SNR 01 33 29.03 +30 42 17.0           ~ 35 0
46 SNR B013042+30269 SNR 01 33 29.1 +30 42 20           ~ 9 0
47 [LBW2010] 37 SNR 01 33 29.45 +30 49 10.6           ~ 25 0
48 [LBW2010] 38 SNR 01 33 30.20 +30 47 45.0           ~ 12 0
49 SNR B013042+30182 SNR 01 33 31.24 +30 33 33.4 18.78 20.65 20.25     ~ 50 0
50 [LBW2010] 40 SR? 01 33 31.34 +30 42 18.3           ~ 7 0
51 [LBW2010] 41 SR? 01 33 31.80 +30 31 01.1           ~ 7 0
52 NGC 595 HII 01 33 33.53 +30 41 29.8           ~ 205 0
53 [LBW2010] 42 SNR 01 33 35.14 +30 23 07.5           ~ 7 0
54 [LBW2010] 43 HII 01 33 35.39 +30 42 32.1           ~ 8 0
55 [LBW2010] 44 SNR 01 33 35.61 +30 49 23.0           ~ 9 0
56 SNR B013047+30211 SNR 01 33 35.92 +30 36 27.5           ~ 44 0
57 SNR B013048+30175 SNR 01 33 37.06 +30 32 53.9           ~ 15 0
58 SNR B013049+30248 SNR 01 33 37.77 +30 40 09.5           ~ 13 0
59 SNR B013049+30270 SNR 01 33 38.01 +30 42 18.2           ~ 13 0
60 [LBW2010] 49 SNR 01 33 40.66 +30 39 40.8           ~ 8 0
61 M33SNR 41 bub 01 33 40.73 +30 42 35.7           ~ 13 1
62 [LBW2010] 51 SNR 01 33 40.80 +30 52 13.0           ~ 11 0
63 [LBW2010] 52 SNR 01 33 41.20 +30 32 28.0           ~ 11 0
64 2MASS J01334162+3032202 V* 01 33 41.6245268592 +30 32 20.263382268 17.47 17.20 16.38   15.30 ~ 11 0
65 [LBW2010] 53 SNR 01 33 41.80 +30 21 02.0           ~ 12 0
66 M33SNR 44 SNR 01 33 41.8036744128 +30 41 49.482025476           ~ 5 0
67 [SB95] 14 PM* 01 33 41.8780494024 +30 38 49.068710268           M5e 15 1
68 [LBW2010] 54 SR? 01 33 42.24 +30 20 57.8           ~ 6 0
69 [LBW2010] 55 SR? 01 33 42.91 +30 41 49.5           ~ 6 0
70 TYC 2293-637-1 * 01 33 43.3884898344 +30 46 30.790826112   11.77 11.37     G5 16 0
71 [LBW2010] 56 SNR 01 33 43.534 +30 41 02.97           ~ 14 0
72 SNR B013055+30208 SNR 01 33 43.70 +30 36 11.5           ~ 12 0
73 [LBW2010] 58 SR? 01 33 45.26 +30 32 20.1           ~ 7 0
74 [LBW2010] 59 SR? 01 33 47.46 +30 39 44.7           ~ 7 0
75 [LBW2010] 60 SR? 01 33 48.35 +30 39 28.4           ~ 6 0
76 SNR B013059+30177 SNR 01 33 48.45 +30 33 05.6     14.2     ~ 36 0
77 RX J0133.8+3029 X 01 33 48.9378842064 +30 29 46.987020852           ~ 9 0
78 [LBW2010] 62 SR? 01 33 49.75 +30 30 49.7           ~ 7 0
79 SNR B013101+30201 SNR 01 33 49.80 +30 35 26.0           ~ 16 0
80 [LBW2010] 63 SR? 01 33 49.90 +30 30 16.7           ~ 7 0
81 M 33 GiG 01 33 50.8965749232 +30 39 36.630403128 6.17 6.27 5.72     ~ 5838 1
82 SNR B013102+30285 SNR 01 33 51.40 +30 43 53.0           ~ 15 0
83 [LBW2010] 66 SNR 01 33 51.60 +30 31 00.0           ~ 12 0
84 [LBW2010] 67 SNR 01 33 51.71 +30 30 43.4           ~ 8 0
85 [LBW2010] 68 bub 01 33 52.15 +30 56 33.4           ~ 6 0
86 [LBW2010] 70 SR? 01 33 54.51 +30 45 18.7           ~ 6 0
87 SNR B013105+30185 SNR 01 33 54.52 +30 33 51.6           ~ 17 0
88 SNR B013106+30178 SNR 01 33 54.88 +30 33 10.6           ~ 45 0
89 [LBW2010] 72 SR? 01 33 55.01 +30 39 57.3           ~ 6 0
90 IC 142 HII 01 33 55.1 +30 45 22   11.30 14.2     ~ 39 0
91 [MPH2006] 188 X 01 33 55.4393890656 +30 23 43.633821696           ~ 6 0
92 [LBW2010] 73 SR? 01 33 56.49 +30 21 27.0           ~ 10 0
93 [LBW2010] 74 SR? 01 33 56.97 +30 34 58.7           ~ 7 0
94 SNR B013108+30196 SNR 01 33 57.033 +30 35 00.70           ~ 14 0
95 [LBW2010] 76 SR? 01 33 57.13 +30 35 06.1           ~ 7 0
96 [LBW2010] 75 SNR 01 33 57.30 +30 40 48.0           ~ 12 0
97 SNR B013109+30168 SNR 01 33 58.04 +30 32 01.3           ~ 16 1
98 [LBW2010] 77 SR? 01 33 58.06 +30 32 09.6           ~ 7 0
99 SNR B013109+30225 SNR 01 33 58.07 +30 37 54.6           ~ 12 0
100 [LBW2010] 79 HII 01 33 58.15 +30 48 36.4           ~ 7 0
101 [LBW2010] 80 SR? 01 33 58.42 +30 36 24.3           ~ 7 0
102 SNR B013110+30210 SNR 01 33 58.5 +30 36 14           ~ 8 0
103 SNR B013110+30182 SNR 01 33 58.51 +30 33 33.1 18.32 19.37 19.52     ~ 22 0
104 [LBW2010] 82 SNR 01 33 58.70 +30 51 54.0           ~ 10 0
105 [MPH2006] 196 SNR 01 33 59.0090983608 +30 34 26.975849412           ~ 7 0
106 [LBW2010] 83 SR? 01 33 59.93 +30 34 21.2           ~ 7 0
107 [LBW2010] 85 SNR 01 34 00.2852599536 +30 47 24.749339136           ~ 9 0
108 SNR B013111+30270 SNR 01 34 00.29 +30 42 18.4           ~ 27 0
109 [LBW2010] 86 SR? 01 34 00.60 +30 49 04.2           ~ 6 0
110 XMMU J013400.4+304905 X 01 34 00.60 +30 49 05.9           ~ 4 0
111 [LBW2010] 87 SNR 01 34 01.34 +30 35 20.2           ~ 10 0
112 [LBW2010] 88 SR? 01 34 02.24 +30 31 06.8           ~ 6 0
113 [HS80] B481 a V* 01 34 02.40 +30 31 03.3   18.58 18.09     ~ 17 0
114 [LBW2010] 89 SR? 01 34 03.31 +30 36 22.9           ~ 6 0
115 SNR B013114+30294 SNR 01 34 03.50 +30 44 43.0           ~ 14 0
116 [LBW2010] 91 SNR 01 34 04.10 +30 32 57.0           ~ 13 0
117 SNR B013118+30210 SNR 01 34 07.23 +30 36 22.0           ~ 10 0
118 ChASeM33 261 X 01 34 07.47 +30 37 07.4           ~ 4 0
119 [LBW2010] 93 SR? 01 34 07.50 +30 37 08.0           ~ 6 0
120 [MPH2006] 205 * 01 34 08.0989695144 +30 46 39.477640368 18.60 19.30 19.20     ~ 10 0
121 [LBW2010] 94 SR? 01 34 08.37 +30 46 33.2           ~ 6 0
122 [LBW2010] 95 SNR 01 34 10.02 +30 47 14.9           ~ 7 0
123 SNR B013121+30271 SNR 01 34 10.67 +30 42 23.6           ~ 42 0
124 [LBW2010] 97 SNR 01 34 11.04 +30 38 59.9           ~ 7 0
125 M33SNR 74 HII 01 34 12.69 +30 35 12.0           ~ 12 1
126 [LBW2010] 99 SNR 01 34 13.02 +30 48 36.1           ~ 7 0
127 SNR B013124+30281 SNR 01 34 13.65 +30 43 27.0           ~ 10 0
128 [LBW2010] 101 SNR 01 34 13.71 +30 48 17.5           ~ 7 0
129 [LBW2010] 102 SR? 01 34 14.10 +30 34 30.9           ~ 6 0
130 [LBW2010] 105 SNR 01 34 14.180 +30 53 52.49           ~ 11 0
131 SNR B013125+30266 SNR 01 34 14.35 +30 41 53.6           ~ 11 0
132 SNR B013125+30244 SNR 01 34 14.38 +30 39 41.6           ~ 10 0
133 [LBW2010] 106 SR? 01 34 14.67 +30 31 50.9           ~ 6 0
134 ChASeM33 J013414.83+303412.3 X 01 34 14.85 +30 34 11.9           ~ 9 0
135 SNR B013126+30176 SNR 01 34 15.70 +30 32 58.0           ~ 16 0
136 [LBW2010] 108 SR? 01 34 16.31 +30 52 32.7           ~ 11 0
137 [MPH2006] 220 SNR 01 34 16.47 +30 51 54.8   16.57 16.22     ~ 11 0
138 M33SNR 84 SNR 01 34 16.50 +30 52 44.0           ~ 5 0
139 [LBW2010] 109 SR? 01 34 17.00 +30 51 47.1           ~ 6 0
140 [LBW2010] 110 SR? 01 34 17.03 +30 33 57.7           ~ 6 0
141 SNR B013125+30192 SNR 01 34 17.1015080968 +30 34 26.476639554           ~ 19 0
142 SNR B013128+30260 SNR 01 34 17.444 +30 41 24.04           ~ 16 0
143 [LBW2010] 112 SR? 01 34 18.32 +30 54 05.8           ~ 7 0
144 SNR B013130+30184 SNR 01 34 19.28 +30 33 45.9           ~ 19 0
145 SNR B013131+30186 SNR 01 34 19.87 +30 33 56.0           ~ 15 0
146 [LBW2010] 115 SNR 01 34 23.23 +30 25 24.9           ~ 7 0
147 [LBW2010] 116 SNR 01 34 23.516 +30 54 26.23           ~ 9 0
148 [LBW2010] 117 SR? 01 34 25.09 +30 54 58.1           ~ 6 0
149 [LBW2010] 118 SNR 01 34 25.41 +30 48 30.9           ~ 7 0
150 [MPH2006] 239 X 01 34 25.79 +30 33 18.4           ~ 6 0
151 [LBW2010] 119 SR? 01 34 25.87 +30 33 16.8           ~ 7 0
152 [LBW2010] 120 SNR 01 34 29.40 +30 41 33.0           ~ 10 0
153 [LBW2010] 121 SNR 01 34 30.40 +30 35 44.0           ~ 11 0
154 [LBW2010] 122 bub 01 34 31.85 +30 56 41.5           ~ 6 0
155 NGC 604 HII 01 34 32.1 +30 47 01           ~ 586 0
156 [LBW2010] 123 SNR 01 34 32.41 +30 35 32.6           ~ 7 0
157 [LBW2010] 124 SNR 01 34 33.01 +30 46 38.8           ~ 23 0
158 [LBW2010] 125 SR? 01 34 35.41 +30 52 12.7           ~ 6 0
159 [LBW2010] 126 SNR 01 34 36.22 +30 36 23.6           ~ 7 0
160 [LBW2010] 127 SNR 01 34 39.00 +30 37 59.8           ~ 7 0
161 [LBW2010] 128 SR? 01 34 40.73 +30 43 36.4           ~ 6 0
162 SNR B013152+30281 SNR 01 34 41.03 +30 43 27.8           ~ 23 0
163 [LBW2010] 130 SR? 01 34 41.23 +30 43 55.4           ~ 6 0
164 [LBW2010] 131 bub 01 34 41.89 +30 37 35.2           ~ 6 0
165 2MASS J01344414+3049199 * 01 34 44.1301768080 +30 49 19.767242640   14.63 13.81     ~ 8 0
166 M33SNR 98 HII 01 34 44.62 +30 42 38.8           ~ 8 1
167 [LBW2010] 133 HII 01 34 54.88 +30 41 17.0           ~ 6 0
168 [LBW2010] 134 SR? 01 34 56.44 +30 36 23.2           ~ 7 0
169 [LBW2010] 135 SR? 01 35 00.36 +30 40 05.0           ~ 6 0
170 [LBW2010] 136 bub 01 35 01.22 +30 38 17.1           ~ 6 0
171 [LBW2010] 137 bub 01 35 03.18 +30 37 09.6           ~ 6 0
172 SNR G130.7+03.1 SNR 02 05 37.0 +64 49 42           ~ 620 4
173 NAME Magellanic Clouds GrG 03 00 -71.0           ~ 7066 0
174 SNR B0450-70.9 SNR 04 49 48.85 -70 51 08.8           ~ 36 0
175 SNR J045949-700835 SNR 04 59 54.00 -70 08 06.0           ~ 57 0
176 SNR B0513-69.2 SNR 05 13 28.20 -69 11 52.0           ~ 17 0
177 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 17434 0
178 NGC 1948 As* 05 24 20.00 -66 24 12.0   10.81 10.61     ~ 105 0
179 SNR J052501-693842 SNR 05 25 02.3 -69 38 39           ~ 401 1
180 SNR J052559-660453 SNR 05 26 00.4 -66 05 02     12.71     ~ 437 2
181 SNR B0527-65.8 SNR 05 27 57.00 -65 49 54.0           ~ 37 0
182 M 1 SNR 05 34 30.9 +22 00 53           ~ 6193 1
183 V* CM Tau Psr 05 34 31.9474694616 +22 00 52.153698024           ~ 5261 0
184 NGC 2029 SNR 05 35 15.5 -67 34 04     12.29     ~ 102 0
185 SN 1987A SN* 05 35 28.020 -69 16 11.07           SNIIpec 4938 2
186 SNR B0535-66.0 SNR 05 35 43.1 -66 01 59           ~ 175 1
187 NAME 30 Dor Nebula SFR 05 38 36.0 -69 05 11           ~ 1190 2
188 LHA 120-N 70 HII 05 43 17.5 -67 50 48           ~ 81 0
189 NGC 2403 AGN 07 36 51.3381434280 +65 36 09.650825640 9.31 8.84 8.38 8.19   ~ 1789 1
190 NAME Pup A BL? 08 24 07 -42 59.8           ~ 600 1
191 M 81 Sy2 09 55 33.1726556496 +69 03 55.062505368   7.89 6.94     ~ 4450 3
192 M 82 AGN 09 55 52.430 +69 40 46.93 9.61 9.30 8.41     ~ 5860 6
193 AJG 14 BL? 12 09 40 -52 25.0           ~ 287 1
194 M 94 SyG 12 50 53.0737971432 +41 07 12.900884628 9.15 8.96 8.24 7.78   ~ 1386 2
195 M 101 GiP 14 03 12.583 +54 20 55.50   8.46 7.86 7.76   ~ 2914 2
196 ESO 134-11 HII 14 40 29 -62 38.7           ~ 565 1
197 NAME Lupus SN SNR 15 02 22.1 -42 05 49           ~ 1328 1
198 NAME Kepler SNR Rad 17 30 40.5 -21 29 14           ~ 795 4
199 NGC 6946 H2G 20 34 52.332 +60 09 13.24   10.5       ~ 2529 2
200 NAME Cyg Loop SNR 20 51.0 +30 40           ~ 913 0
201 3C 461 BL? 23 23 24.000 +58 48 54.00     14.30     ~ 2792 1
202 NGC 7793 GiG 23 57 49.7540045856 -32 35 27.701550744 10.26 9.74 9.28 9.06 9.7 ~ 1107 2
203 NAME Local Group GrG ~ ~           ~ 8391 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2010ApJS..187..495L and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu